Labor is one of the largest expenses in a restaurant.
It is also one of the easiest costs to lose control of without realizing it.
A schedule can look perfectly reasonable when it is posted. Then sales come in lower than expected, the restaurant stays fully staffed, and suddenly labor percentage is climbing.
By the time payroll hits, the money has already been spent.
The goal is not to run short-staffed.
The goal is to make sure staffing matches the level of business your restaurant is actually doing.
Here are some of the biggest signs that your restaurant may be overscheduled and what operators can watch before restaurant labor cost gets away from them.
One of the clearest signs of overscheduling is simple.
Sales go down, but labor hours do not.
If your restaurant normally does $20,000 in sales on a Friday and schedules accordingly, that staffing level may make sense.
But if the following Friday comes in at $14,000 and the same number of employees work the same number of hours, your labor percentage will increase.
The schedule may not have changed.
The business did.
That is why labor should be reviewed alongside actual sales, not just the schedule that was built days earlier.
Restaurants are busy places, and schedules often become repetitive.
Managers may start thinking:
That can be convenient, but it can also become expensive.
Sales patterns change throughout the year. Seasonality changes. Weather changes. Local events change. Guest traffic changes.
Staffing should reflect what the restaurant needs now, not simply what it needed three months ago.
A schedule should be a plan, not a habit.
A restaurant can be busy for part of a shift and still be overscheduled overall.
Maybe lunch is strong from noon to 1:30. Then business slows down dramatically.
If the entire team remains scheduled until 4:00, those slower hours can quickly add unnecessary labor cost.
Operators should look beyond total daily sales and consider when the sales are actually happening.
Sometimes the opportunity is not reducing the number of employees scheduled.
It is adjusting start times, break times, cut times, or shift lengths.
A small adjustment across multiple employees can have a meaningful impact on labor percentage.
Your labor percentage should not exist in a vacuum. It needs a target.
If your budget says labor should be 28 percent and you are consistently running at 31 or 32 percent, that difference deserves attention.
The question becomes: Why?
It could be too many hours. It could be overtime. It could be slower sales. It could be training hours. It could be a change in wage rates. It could be a combination of several things.
The important part is recognizing the difference early enough to investigate it.
Without a customized restaurant budget, operators may know what labor cost is, but they do not always know whether it is where it should be.
Overtime can quietly increase restaurant labor cost.
Sometimes it is necessary. An employee calls out. Someone stays late. A manager covers an unexpected shift. Those things happen.
But frequent overtime may point to a scheduling issue.
If the same employees regularly hit overtime while other team members have available hours, the problem may not be staffing levels.
It may be how the hours are being distributed.
Operators should keep an eye on employees approaching overtime before the end of the week. Once those hours are worked, there is no opportunity to take them back.
Managers often know when the restaurant is slower than expected.
The problem is that they may hesitate to adjust staffing.
They hope business picks up. They wait another hour. Then another.
By the time cuts are made, several unnecessary labor hours may already have accumulated.
This does not mean sending employees home at the first sign of a slow period. It means giving managers clear expectations around when staffing should be reevaluated.
If sales are tracking well below budget, the labor plan may need to change with them.
Good labor management happens during the shift, not only when the next schedule is written.
A manager should not have to guess whether labor is too high.
They should be able to see how the restaurant is performing.
That means understanding:
When managers can see the numbers, labor becomes easier to manage.
They can make decisions based on what is actually happening instead of relying entirely on instinct.
There is no single labor percentage that works for every restaurant.
The right number depends on your concept, service model, menu, location, wages, hours of operation, and overall business structure.
A full-service restaurant may have a very different labor model than a quick-service concept.
The important number is the labor percentage your restaurant needs in order to reach its budget and profit goals.
That gives your team something specific to manage toward.
Instead of asking: "Is our labor high?"
You can ask: "Are we above or below our labor budget today?"
That is a much more useful question.
Controlling restaurant labor cost does not mean cutting staff as aggressively as possible.
That can create a different set of problems:
The goal is balance.
You need enough people to deliver the experience your customers expect without scheduling more labor than the level of business requires.
The strongest operators find that balance by connecting staffing decisions to sales and budget.
This is the biggest issue with labor.
Once payroll hits, the opportunity to fix those hours is gone.
If you discover at the end of the month that labor was several points over budget, you know what happened. But you cannot change it.
If you can see that labor is trending high today, you still have options.
You can review upcoming schedules. You can watch overtime. You can adjust shift times. You can prepare managers to make cuts when sales are slower than expected.
You can make a change before one bad week becomes a bad month.
Proactive P&L helps restaurant operators compare sales, labor, expenses, and budget performance throughout the month.
Instead of finding out later that labor was higher than expected, operators can see how the restaurant is performing and identify areas that need attention sooner.
That gives owners and managers the information they need to make better decisions while those decisions can still affect the outcome.
Because the best time to discover that you are overscheduled is not after payroll. It is while you still have time to do something about it.
See how Proactive P&L can help you monitor labor, compare performance to budget, and understand what is happening in your restaurant throughout the month.
From concept developer and restaurant general manager, to corporate chef and marketing director, Murphy has been the lead executive in a number of the country’s most prominent restaurants and bars. Connect with Geordy on geo@cypresshospitalitygroup.com
Restaurant food costs have been under pressure for years. So when food cost starts climbing, inflation is often blamed. But it may not be the whole problem.
Restaurant prime cost combines your two largest controllable expenses—cost of goods sold and labor—into one clear benchmark.
Delve into actionable strategies tailored to various restaurant concepts, providing insights to lower labor costs effectively across all shifts.
